Attorney Owner Wins $201K In Condo Association Wastebasket War

Martha Neil, ABA Journal

A nuisance provision contained in many condominium association governing documents can be a tempting basis for litigation.

But it backfired for one Florida condominium association that tried to utilize it to force an attorney owner out of her home, writes local lawyer Jean Winters on the Condos and HOAs page of the South Florida Sun-Sentinel.

A protracted legal battle began eight years ago with a dispute over whether or not Alca Condominium Association, Inc. in Miami would grant owner Nancy Wear’s request to put a wastebasket near her mailbox so she could throw away junk mail on the spot. When the association refused, she began tossing mail on the floor, the article recounts.

The battle escalated, and the association sought to have Wear declared a nuisance in arbitration so she could be evicted. A seasoned trial attorney, she successfully pursued the matter in state court and won a jury verdict. That was overturned, but last year an appeals court reinstated it and in June Wear was awarded attorney’s fees.

Read more here

Share

St. Petersburg Times Editorial Calls for Fixing HOA Loophole

Florida legislators can’t anticipate every legal loophole that some unscrupulous person will exploit, which is why they have to stay nimble and respond to scams when they arise. The latest one demanding a legislative response is an opening in state foreclosure law that allows investors to get title to properties for pennies on the dollar by satisfying outstanding homeowners association dues, then exploit those properties and profit until a bank forecloses. This has got to be fixed to protect homeowners, renters and other creditors.

If there is a moral to this tale, it’s never underestimate the ingenuity of people looking to take advantage of a system that is under stress, such as the foreclosure process during the housing market meltdown in Florida. The sheer volume of foreclosures in the state, combined with the national robo-signing scandal, has resulted in banks taking years to foreclose on delinquent homeowners. This limbo has created serious problems for homeowners and condominium associations, which rely on regular dues for everything from maintenance of common areas to other expenses.

Florida law allows homeowners associations to foreclose on properties when dues are in arrears. But the associations are not required to alert the mortgage-holding banks of their intentions. That’s where the scammers come in.

A series of reports by St. Petersburg Times staff writers Kris Hundley and Susan Taylor Martin exposed the way investor groups, some made up of people with criminal histories, gain title to millions of dollars of property through homeowners association foreclosures, with the intention of pocketing rent money on the property until the first mortgage holder forecloses. Hundley and Martin documented situations where investors obtained title to a $1.2 million bayfront home in Apollo Beach for $10,010 and a 3,700-square-foot North Tampa home for $8,090.

Read more here

Share

Florida HOAs Can Now Demand Rent Checks Of Deadbeat Owners Directly From Renter

Tolusa Olorunnipa, Miami Herald

A new law offers a stark choice for South Florida condo renters living in units owned by people who are behind on their maintenance fees: Fork over the rent money to the association, or face eviction.

The “Distressed Condominium Relief Act,” signed by Gov. Charlie Crist on June 1 and active as of Thursday, gives condo associations the right to demand renters in delinquent units to pay rent directly to the association rather than to unit owners. While the law offers protections for renters who comply, those who don’t could face eviction.

It’s the latest development in an ongoing saga between cash-starved condo associations, and investor-owners who have stopped paying condo maintenance fees since the market crashed.

Omar Ibrahem, who moved out of a rental last year because its owner went into foreclosure, said he hadn’t received any notices about the new law at the unit he rents on Miami’s Brickell Avenue.

“I haven’t heard or haven’t received any notices that they are pursuing delinquencies,” he said. But after his experience last year, he plans to monitor the situation carefully.

After years of penny pinching and legal maneuvering to collect maintenance fees from sometimes-recalcitrant condominium owners, condo associations are looking to the new law to help increase cash flow.

Renters, who have flocked to condos by the thousands in areas like downtown Miami and South Beach since the crash, are suddenly in the spotlight. Many have been living in modern buildings with a slew of amenities, often unaware that condo owners had stopped paying the fees that fund them.

Beginning this month, some renters will receive letters asking them to fork over rent money directly to condo association boards. Unit owners will not be allowed to take any action against renters who pay a portion or all of their rent to the association.

“It gives the tenants more peace of mind,” said Jon Mann, owner of Five Star International Realty in Miami. “They can pay the association a portion of their rent and they know they won’t be kicked out.”

But lawyers and homeowner association members say the law’s wording isn’t completely clear. The most hotly debated point is whether or not associations can collect payment for past due fees that have accrued over time, or only for monthly assessments due after July 1.

“My recommendation to my clients is to act conservatively, because this law is brand new,” said Lisa Magill an attorney at Hollywood-based Becker & Poliakoff, a large condo association law firm.

But many condo boards, severely strapped for cash, are taking the more aggressive position, said Bill Worrall, corporate vice president of property management company The Continental Group.

“Practically, the association will collect 100 percent of the rent until the account is brought current,” said Worrall.

For example, a renter paying $1,000 a month for a condo unit that is $5,000 behind on monthly fees might be asked to turn over his entire rent check to the condo association for five months, and then hand over a portion of his rent to cover fees for the remainder of the lease.

Delinquency rates have surged in recent years as the economy has tanked along with home values, leaving some investors acting in bad faith and the newly unemployed unable to pay maintenance fees.

The investors, who have opted to “strategically default,” or intentionally abandon a mortgage along with associated fees, often do so in bulk, leaving a trail of foreclosures and a gaping hole in many condo association budgets.

Read more: http://www.miamiherald.com/2010/06/30/1709704/with-new-law-condos-get-new-tool.html#ixzz0sQvsBpxo

Share

Ruling may help homeowner associations

From Historiccity.com

Any Historic City News reader that has either owned a condominium, or a home in a community with a mandatory homeowner association, understands the importance of paying the monthly maintenance assessment on time.

That maintenance fee represents the total costs required to pay for things like insurance on the common areas — as well as their upkeep and repair, landscaping, utility bills, pool maintenance, management and other professional fees. The actual bills are totaled and divided by the owner’s share of interest in the common elements in the community and approved, every year, by the Board of Directors at an annual meeting of the homeowners.

Like most things in life, everything is fine until something goes wrong. In the declining real estate market in St. Johns County, we see homes that sold as recently as five years ago for $250,000, today being sold, in foreclosure, for as little as $175,000 — or less. Around the state, things are no better; in Miami-Dade there are more than 115,000 open foreclosure cases with 7,000 more being filed each month.

So, what happens to owners in homeowner associations if one or more of the owners can no longer afford to keep their home? The mortgage lender takes the property back in foreclosure, right? The answer is yes, with a caveat.

When the bank takes title to the house, they assume all of the owner’s obligations going forward — including the obligation for the apportioned share of the maintenance fees. Now, this becomes an additional burden and monthly expense to the bank.

In the meantime, the association is trying to pay its vendors their monthly charges and when financially distressed owners stop paying their mortgage — they tend to stop paying their monthly maintenance fees. You would be surprised how quickly a financially healthy homeowner association can go broke — keep in mind, the association operates as a non-profit entity. It serves largely as a conduit for individual owners to pay their portion of bills incurred in common with all of the other owners.

http://www.historiccity.com/2010/staugustine/news/florida/ruling-may-help-homeowner-associations-2546

Share